Sunday Special: A Sea of Streaming Docs

Summary of Sunday Special: A Sea of Streaming Docs

by The New York Times

50m•November 16, 2025
Listen to Episode

Overview of Sunday Special: A Sea of Streaming Docs

Host Gilbert Cruz is joined by NYT movie critic Alyssa Wilkinson and chief TV critic James Poniewozik to survey today’s documentary boom — why docs are everywhere on streaming services, how the form has changed, and what’s worth watching now. The episode centers on Ken Burns’s new 12‑hour series The American Revolution and expands into documentary subgenres (true crime, nature, sports, celebrity/reputation films), production/funding realities, and a rapid-fire recommendations segment.

Guests and context

  • Host: Gilbert Cruz (The New York Times)
  • Guests: Alyssa Wilkinson (movie critic, writes the “Documentary Lens” column) and James Poniewozik (chief TV critic; reviewed Ken Burns’s The American Revolution)
  • Focus: Ken Burns’s new series; the documentary marketplace; genre trends; recommendations

Ken Burns and The American Revolution

  • Structure/style: Familiar Burns techniques — archival photos, historian talking heads, scripted narration, and cinematic pacing — co-directed with Sarah Botstein and David Schmidt.
  • Scope: A six‑part, 12‑hour history intended for the country’s 250th anniversary; aims to broaden the usual Revolution narrative to include Native nations (Iroquois Confederacy), loyalists, and enslaved Americans.
  • Notable reframing: Presents some conventional figures in a more complicated light (e.g., George Washington praised as a symbol but not portrayed as an infallible battlefield genius).
  • Cultural role: Burns is presented as an influential public‑TV historian whose work helps form a national historical canon; guests argue his projects can be both comforting and subtly radical because they promote inclusive, civic narratives on a public platform.

The current documentary landscape — trends & realities

  • Proliferation of content: Streaming platforms have created a glut of documentaries across genres.
  • Money matters: Funding follows perceived audience demand; series about cults, true crime, and celebrity reputation documentaries are relatively easy to finance and distribute, while long-term investigative films struggle to secure funds.
  • Time-intensive investigations: Films like The Alabama Solution demonstrate that impactful, change-oriented documentaries often require years of work (and thus are harder to monetize).
  • Meta commentary: A second wave of documentaries now interrogates the true- crime genre itself (e.g., films that critique the ethics and sensationalism of true‑crime storytelling).

Key subgenres discussed

  • True crime: Boomed after hits like HBO’s The Jinx and Netflix’s Making a Murderer. Critics accept true-crime that has a distinct voice or broader idea rather than lurid detail.
  • Nature: Technological advances (camera gear, access) make modern nature docs visually spectacular; producers wrestle with how to taxonomize ever-similar series.
  • Sports: From ESPN’s 30 for 30 to The Last Dance, sports docs reshape mass-culture moments into human stories; raw sports footage is versatile material for political, social, and character-driven narratives.
  • Celebrity/“reputation” films: Documentaries that either burnish or unpack celebrity are common and platform-friendly.
  • Political/persuasive documentaries: Still present but face funding and distribution challenges unless paired with star power or platform backing.

Notable quotes & insights

  • Ken Burns + public TV: “Those two things can’t be taken apart from one another” — Burns’s work embodies public television’s mission to create shared civic stories.
  • On what makes a documentary matter: Beyond facts, critics want a “take” — an argument or idea that reframes the subject.
  • On genre fatigue: True-crime’s tropes have become so familiar that some recent films are self-aware commentaries on the genre.

Recommended documentaries mentioned (short notes + availability given on episode)

Note: streaming availability noted where guests mentioned it on the show.

  • Ken Burns — The American Revolution (new, 6 parts / 12 hours) — explored in depth in episode
  • Pee‑wee as Himself (about Paul Reubens / Pee‑wee Herman) — Jim recommends; available on HBO Max/Max
  • The Remarkable Life of Ibelin (described as a moving film using World of Warcraft chat logs to tell a confined young man’s life) — Alyssa recommends; mentioned as streaming on Netflix
  • Camera Person (Kirsten Johnson, 2016) — memoir through B‑roll; Alyssa recommends; streaming on HBO Max (as noted)
  • Look Into My Eyes (Lana Wilson, psychics) — Alyssa recommends; A24 release, streaming (mentioned HBO Max)
  • An American Family (1973 TV documentary series) — Jim recommends as a landmark docu‑series (not widely streaming; partial uploads exist)
  • Ladies and Gentlemen … The 50 Years of SNL Music (Questlove-curated SNL music archive special) — Jim recommends; available on Peacock
  • When We Were Kings (Leon Gast, 1996) — rumble in the jungle/Muhammad Ali; Jim’s favorite sports doc
  • The Last Dance (Michael Jordan docu‑series) and Tiger King — cited as pandemic-era cultural moments
  • The Jinx, Making a Murderer — catalysts for the true‑crime boom
  • The Alabama Solution — example of a long‑term investigative film using footage from inside prisons (discussed, not necessarily widely available)
  • The Act of Killing and The Gleaners & I — cited as among the 21st century’s best nonfiction films

Also referenced via quiz clips (examples of notable narrators/films): March of the Penguins (Morgan Freeman), Grizzly Man (Werner Herzog), Five Came Back (Meryl Streep), Before the Flood (Leonardo DiCaprio), The Silent World (Jacques Cousteau).

Practical takeaways / quick watchlist (for readers who want to dive in)

  • If you want a canonical, public‑TV history: Watch Ken Burns’s The American Revolution (new).
  • To see a documentary about craft/ethics of filmmaking: Camera Person (Kirsten Johnson).
  • For an emotionally surprising form: The (Netflix) film that reconstructs a young man’s online life via World of Warcraft logs (referred to in episode as The Remarkable Life of Ibelin).
  • If you want pop-culture + music history: Ladies and Gentlemen … 50 Years of SNL Music (Peacock).
  • For sports-as-drama: When We Were Kings (rumble in the jungle) and The Last Dance.
  • To study the rise and complications of true crime: Start with The Jinx and Making a Murderer; then try recent meta-docs that interrogate the genre.

Episode format & extras

  • The show includes a quiz/game segment (documentary trivia and narration-identification) that highlights well-known doc narrators and subjects.
  • Host and guests promised a show‑notes list of all films discussed (check episode notes for the full list).

Bottom line

The episode positions documentary filmmaking as both democratized (mass streaming availability) and precarious (funding favors genres that attract quick audiences). Ken Burns remains a defining figure for long‑form public history, but critics emphasize that the most interesting documentary work today is wide-ranging — pushing form, investigating long-term stories, and reflecting on what it means to look at other people. The conversation closes with several eclectic recommendations spanning classic and contemporary nonfiction.