Loud, Messy, Physical - What To Do When Kids Won't Stop Fighting

Summary of Loud, Messy, Physical - What To Do When Kids Won't Stop Fighting

by JLML Press

28m•November 10, 2026
Listen to Episode

Overview of Unruffled Episode: “Loud, Messy, Physical - What To Do When Kids Won't Stop Fighting”

In this episode, Janet Lansbury responds to a parent worried about intense sibling conflict between a spirited, physical 2.5-year-old and a logical, sensitive 4.5-year-old. Her central message is that sibling conflict is not only normal, but often an important part of how children learn social skills. Rather than trying to stop every argument, parents are encouraged to trust their children more, intervene less, and step in only when truly needed—while staying neutral and calm.

The Core Problem

The parent describes a recurring pattern:

  • The younger child copies, provokes, or claims things that don’t make sense.
  • The older child reacts by yelling, getting frustrated, or escalating.
  • The younger child often responds with hitting or biting.
  • The parent feels pulled into the conflict and sometimes physically removes the younger child, which can intensify the situation.

Janet emphasizes that this dynamic is common, especially among siblings who are close in age and size and who interact like peers.

Main Takeaways

1. Conflict is part of healthy learning

Janet argues that children learn a great deal through conflict with siblings and peers:

  • negotiation
  • emotional regulation
  • reading social cues
  • standing up for themselves
  • tolerating frustration

Trying to erase conflict too quickly can rob kids of these learning opportunities.

2. Parents often over-assign themselves responsibility

A major theme is that parents tend to believe it’s their job to:

  • make sure the older child “understands” the younger one
  • prevent all escalation
  • fix the conflict in the moment

Janet encourages parents to loosen that burden and recognize that much of this is normal developmental behavior, not a parenting failure.

3. Children usually know what they’re doing

Janet says the older child is not necessarily confused about the younger child’s behavior. She likely understands that her brother is pushing buttons, and he likely knows exactly how to get a reaction from her. The conflict is often about attention, power, and engagement—not literal misunderstanding.

4. The parent’s involvement often fuels the drama

When adults become visibly uncomfortable, the conflict can intensify because:

  • it adds pressure and urgency
  • it turns the conflict into a “with mom” or “against mom” dynamic
  • it can make children feel judged or ganged up on

Janet’s advice: intervene minimally and avoid becoming a third participant in the drama.

Janet’s Practical Approach

Step 1: Put the situation in perspective

Remind yourself:

  • sibling conflict is normal
  • loud, messy play and arguments are part of learning
  • both children are involved, not just one “bad” child

Step 2: Trust both children

Assume:

  • your older child understands more than you may think
  • your younger child is not helpless or clueless
  • both are capable of learning through their interactions

Step 3: Share a simple plan during calm moments

Have a neutral conversation when everyone is calm:

  • Let them know you expect arguments sometimes.
  • Tell them they can ask for help if they need it.
  • Encourage them to try handling disagreements themselves first.

Step 4: Offer coaching, not refereeing

If you do give input, do it like a calm coach or mediator:

  • “I see you’re frustrated.”
  • “You can move back if he’s too close.”
  • “It’s okay to be mad, but not to bite.”
  • “Try taking a step away.”

Avoid taking sides or making one child into the villain.

Step 5: Stay neutral

Janet repeats the mantra:

  • neutral, neutral, neutral

That means:

  • reflecting without judgment
  • not shaming either child
  • not overreacting
  • not escalating the emotional tone

Step 6: Use the least intervention necessary

If safety is the issue, use the smallest effective response:

  • block instead of grabbing
  • guide instead of lifting
  • separate only if needed
  • avoid “catastrophizing” the moment

Janet specifically warns against over-responding physically, because strong intervention can signal to children that the situation is more alarming than it really is.

What Janet Thinks the Parent Did Wrong — and Why It’s Understandable

The parent tried telling the older child, in front of the younger one, that “he’s two” and that his behavior is just how two-year-olds are. Janet says this was understandable, but not ideal because:

  • it creates comparison
  • it can feel like a subtle alliance with one child
  • it may leave the younger child feeling excluded or judged

She stresses that parents should not beat themselves up for these instincts—almost everyone does this at first.

Important Distinction: Minimal Intervention vs. Neglect

Janet addresses a likely objection: this approach is not the same as ignoring bullying or letting a child get hurt.

Her point is:

  • stay engaged
  • be available
  • intervene when necessary
  • but don’t overmanage every conflict

She also notes that a child who is aggressively acting out may be doing so partly because they feel judged or rejected, and neutrality helps reduce that dynamic.

Final Message

Janet’s overall philosophy is that sibling conflict is often where real social learning happens. Parents can help most by:

  • trusting their children
  • staying calm
  • intervening sparingly
  • avoiding judgment
  • giving kids room to work things out

Her closing message is reassuring: kids are more capable than we often assume, and parents are too.

Notable Sponsor Mentions

The episode also includes sponsor segments for:

  • Wayfair — holiday/home hosting products
  • Monday.com — AI work platform
  • Tin Can — kid-safe landline phone
  • Quince — clothing and gift items with premium feel and lower prices

These are promotional interruptions and not part of the parenting discussion.