Is the 2026 Housing Market Finally Becoming “Unstuck”? (Rookie Reply)

Summary of Is the 2026 Housing Market Finally Becoming “Unstuck”? (Rookie Reply)

by BiggerPockets

29m•March 6, 2026
Listen to Episode

Overview of Is the 2026 Housing Market Finally Becoming “Unstuck”? (Rookie Reply)

This episode of the Real Estate Rookie podcast (BiggerPockets) answers three listener questions focused on rookie pain points: closing your first deal, adjusting investing strategy when market sales slow, and calculating ARV (after repair value) when investing remotely. Hosts Ashley Kerr and Tony J. Robinson share personal anecdotes, common surprises, and practical steps you can take to reduce risk and speed execution.

Key takeaways

  • The jump from analysis to wiring money is emotionally real — celebrate the milestone but prepare for surprises.
  • Always carry reserves: even well-underwritten projects can reveal unexpected expenses (electrical upgrades, septic pumps, etc.).
  • Local market data matters more than national headlines. Look at days on market, pending sales, pricing trends, and micro-markets.
  • Don’t rely solely on wholesalers’ ARVs — verify comps and appraisals yourself.
  • Speed and prep matter on renovations: pre-order long-lead items and coordinate demo to start the day you get keys to minimize holding costs.
  • Tight underwriting and discipline are essential in slower markets; deal volume may drop but opportunities remain.

1) Closing your first deal — common surprises & practical tips

  • Psychological moment: wiring funds can be nerve-wracking but is a culmination of learning and action.
  • Real surprises shared:
    • Unexpected electrical panel upgrade (~$800) discovered during HVAC install.
    • Septic backups on a short-term rental because a septic inspection was skipped.
  • Practical advice:
    • Always keep contingency reserves for unexpected repairs.
    • Conduct area-specific inspections (septic, wells, local utilities) — ask your agent what’s common in that locale.
    • Walk the inspection with the inspector; get priorities and estimated timelines/costs (immediate, 1 year, 5 years, 10 years).
    • Use property-management/tenant portals from day one instead of manual checks and text-based maintenance requests (examples: TurboTenant).
    • If renovating, plan to start demo/furnishing on day-of-closing. Pre-order long-lead items (furniture, tile) even before closing when reasonable.
    • Negotiate for seller repairs during the inspection window (e.g., mold remediation, re-venting bath ducts).

2) Adjusting strategy when sales slow (market outlook & investor responses)

  • Why 2025–2026 felt sticky:
    • Higher prices paired with elevated mortgage rates created affordability constraints.
    • Lock-in effect: homeowners with low rates (3–4%) are reluctant to list, decreasing inventory.
    • Result: lower transaction volume in many areas, increased importance of conservative underwriting.
  • How investors can adapt:
    • Analyze your specific local market — pockets may still have strong demand (low inventory + high rental interest).
    • Track pending sales and days-on-market, not just sold data.
    • Maintain discipline: be ready to say “no” and avoid inflating returns to justify marginal deals.
    • Consider shifting tactics (flip → rental or hold longer) only if it matches your underwriting and goals.
    • Shop lenders and ask about incentives (customer relationships, local credit unions, bundled accounts) — small rate differences materially affect deal viability.
    • Watch rate movement and re-check rate locks if closings are delayed.

3) Determining ARV remotely — reliable methods & tools

  • Understand motivations:
    • Wholesalers often present optimistic ARVs because their fee depends on it. Treat their ARV as one data point, not the final word.
  • Steps to validate ARV remotely:
    • Pull your own comps. Use MLS (via an agent), Zillow, PropStream, Privy, or similar tools.
    • Build a comp spreadsheet: include listing price, purchase price, pending date, close date, days on market, and differences in beds/baths/sqft/lot.
    • Prefer recent closed sales and pending sales for current market signals. Pay attention to pending → close lags (market shifting).
    • Request recent appraisals from local agents — appraisals reveal the radius, adjustments for beds/baths/sqft, and logic behind comps.
    • Verify each comp’s details (accurate bedroom/bath counts, correct neighborhood/utility differences).
    • Apply consistent plus/minus adjustments for differences (bed/bath, square footage, lot) based on local patterns or appraisal logic.
    • Consider hiring a local appraiser or experienced agent to run comps if you can’t reliably access MLS data.
  • Practical tips:
    • Use the purchase price from closed sales (not original listing) as the comp metric.
    • Check for miscategorized listings (wrong zip, wrong town) which can skew comps.
    • If comps are sparse, widen radius carefully and apply adjustments conservatively.

Actionable checklist (what to do next)

  • Before closing:
    • Confirm you have reserves (contingency fund for unexpected electrical, septic, HVAC etc.).
    • Schedule and attend a thorough inspection; request prioritized fixes and estimates.
    • Pre-order long-lead renovation/furnishing items if you’re confident the deal will close.
    • Set up property-management software and online rent collection.
  • If market feels slow:
    • Analyze local pending sales and days on market.
    • Re-run underwriting, tighten assumptions, be willing to walk from marginal deals.
    • Ask lenders about rate incentives and re-check rate locks if delays occur.
  • When evaluating remote flips/wholesale deals:
    • Pull your own comps and create a comp spreadsheet (include pending/closing dates).
    • Request recent appraisals or agent-exported sold lists.
    • Use multiple data sources (MLS via agent, Zillow, PropStream, Privy) and be conservative with ARV adjustments.

Notable quotes

  • “Reserves, reserves, reserves are so important.” — on why contingency funds are essential.
  • “Use whatever [a wholesaler] proposes as a single data point but do not make any definitive decisions on whatever ARV a wholesaler provides.” — on validating ARV.

This episode is practical and tactical: it reassures rookies that surprises are normal, emphasizes local data and discipline over national headlines, and gives concrete steps for closing, renovating, and comping deals when you’re not onsite.