The story we don't tell about how this country was founded

Summary of The story we don't tell about how this country was founded

by NPR

37m•July 3, 2026
Listen to Episode

Overview of The story we don't tell about how this country was founded

This NPR Code Switch episode introduces Rebecca Nagle’s podcast series First America and argues that the United States’ founding story is incomplete without Native people at the center. The episode challenges the familiar Revolutionary War narrative—taxation, liberty, and independence—by showing that anti-Indigenous violence, land hunger, and the desire to control Native territory were foundational to the American Revolution and to the country itself.

Main Takeaways

  • Native people were not peripheral to U.S. history; they were central to it.

    • The episode argues that standard American origin stories erase Indigenous nations and their role in shaping colonial politics and resistance.

  • The Declaration of Independence contains explicit anti-Indigenous language.

    • Beyond “all men are created equal,” the document includes a complaint against “merciless Indian savages,” revealing that hatred of Native people coexisted with revolutionary ideals.

  • Land was a major driver of revolution.

    • Colonists were furious about Britain’s attempts to limit westward expansion through the 1763 Proclamation Line, which protected Indigenous land and frustrated settlers, land speculators, and elites like George Washington.

  • Early colonial rebellion was tied to Indigenous land and diplomacy, not just taxes.

    • The episode highlights frontier conflict, especially during Pontiac’s War, as a major precursor to revolutionary unrest.
    • Colonists attacked British efforts to make peace with Native nations, showing that their anger often centered on Native sovereignty and access to land.

  • The founding era normalized anti-Indigenous violence.

    • The story traces how colonists defined themselves in opposition to Indigenous people, using dehumanizing language and violence to build a shared settler identity.

Fort Snelling: A Symbol of Historical Continuity

Rebecca Nagle’s reporting at Fort Snelling in Minneapolis becomes a key example of how history is layered onto the present.

What happened there historically

  • Fort Snelling was built on Dakota sacred land.
  • In 1862, it became the site of a concentration camp where more than 1,600 Dakota people were imprisoned.
  • The broader campaign against the Dakota included:
    • forced removal
    • death marches
    • massacres
    • bounties on Indigenous people
    • starvation and abuse

Why the site matters now

  • Fort Snelling is also where ICE’s Minneapolis headquarters is located.
  • While Nagle was reporting, ICE agents shot and killed Renee Good during a confrontation in Minneapolis.
  • The episode draws a direct line between:
    • Indigenous displacement and state violence in the 1800s
    • modern immigration enforcement and militarized policing

Present-Day Parallels

The episode argues that today’s authoritarian tactics are not new or uniquely modern.

  • Violent roundups and detention have precedents in U.S. history
  • The state has long used force against marginalized groups
  • What is often described as “un-American” is actually deeply American

Nagle suggests that the current political moment becomes easier to understand when viewed as part of a long historical pattern rather than as an anomaly.

Key Insight

One of the episode’s central arguments is:

If we don’t understand the full context in which the nation was founded, we won’t understand the full context of the country now.

In other words, the United States’ present struggles with racism, authoritarianism, and state violence are not departures from its founding principles—they are rooted in them.

Notable Historical Figures and Ideas

  • Rebecca Nagle — Cherokee Nation citizen, host of First America
  • Nick Estes — historian and Lower Brule Sioux Tribe citizen
  • Ned Blackhawk — Western Shoshone historian at Yale
  • Pontiac — Odawa leader who organized Indigenous resistance
  • Neolin — Delaware/Lenape prophet tied to Indigenous anti-colonial vision
  • George Washington — presented as a land speculator invested in westward expansion
  • Declaration of Independence — reframed as both a statement of ideals and a document shaped by anti-Indigenous politics

Closing Message

The episode ultimately reframes American history as a story of Indigenous erasure, land theft, and state violence—one that continues into the present. Its core claim is that understanding the United States honestly requires confronting the parts of its origin story that have been left out.