Overview of Can Trump steal the midterms?
Vox’s America Actually episode examines whether Donald Trump and his administration could meaningfully interfere with the midterms by attacking mail voting, voter rolls, and election administration. The central conclusion: the immediate risk of a stolen or disrupted election is relatively low because U.S. elections are decentralized and courts have repeatedly blocked federal overreach. But the bigger damage is political—Trump’s constant fraud claims have sown confusion, eroded trust, and could suppress turnout if voters become discouraged.
Key Takeaways
-
The most alarming threats have mostly been checked.
- Courts blocked Trump executive orders that tried to alter voter registration and mail voting rules.
- The DOJ’s push to obtain unredacted voter files from states has largely failed; the administration lost 26 related cases.
-
Election administration is mostly local and state-driven.
- States and local election officials control registration, ballot handling, and voter list maintenance.
- The president does not have authority to set election rules.
-
Claims of widespread noncitizen voting are not supported by evidence.
- National studies and state audits show noncitizen voting is vanishingly rare.
- Isolated errors, such as a DMV software mistake in New Jersey, show the system catching problems—not a systemic crisis.
-
The SAVE Act would be a major barrier to voting.
- It would require documentary proof of citizenship to register or re-register.
- The Brennan Center argues this would block millions of eligible voters who lack easy access to passports, birth certificates, or matching documents.
-
The biggest long-term danger is not election theft but voter distrust.
- Trump’s campaign has worked to make people doubt the system.
- That strategy only succeeds if people stop participating.
Main Topics Discussed
1) How safe are free and fair elections this November?
The expert from the Brennan Center says the risk is relatively low. Voting rights advocates and local officials have largely contained the Trump administration’s efforts to meddle in election administration through litigation and state resistance.
2) Mail voting and ballot access
The episode pushes back on claims that mail voting is inherently insecure. Mail ballots remain a normal, legal, and popular way to vote, and voters are reminded that many states offer multiple return options, including:
- USPS mail delivery
- Drop boxes
- Election office drop-off
- Polling place drop-off in some states
3) Voter rolls and noncitizen voting
The transcript emphasizes that:
- Voter list maintenance is a state responsibility
- Mistakes happen, but systems exist to fix them
- Noncitizen voting is extremely rare and not a meaningful threat to election outcomes
4) Why the SAVE Act is controversial
The SAVE Act is framed as a “show your papers” law. Critics argue it would make registration harder for:
- Students
- Rural voters
- People who move often
- People whose current name doesn’t match their documents
- Working families who lack time or money to obtain updated paperwork
5) The consequences of not passing federal voting rights reform
The discussion argues that failure to pass measures like the Freedom to Vote Act and the John Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act has left voters exposed to:
- Restrictive state voting laws
- Weakened protections against racial discrimination
- Partisan gerrymandering
- A patchwork of rules that differ dramatically by state
6) Supreme Court decisions and gerrymandering
The episode highlights how the Supreme Court has gradually weakened the Voting Rights Act and allowed partisan gerrymandering to flourish. The result, according to the guest, is a system where elected officials are increasingly choosing their voters instead of the other way around.
What Voters Should Do
Practical election-day advice
- Check your registration status early
- Confirm your address is up to date
- Learn your state’s ballot return options
- Don’t assume results will be final on Election Night
- Vote with friends or family if possible
Be patient with results
Some states count ballots that arrive after Election Day, which means final tallies may take days. The episode stresses that delayed results are not evidence of fraud—they’re a feature of a decentralized system trying to count every valid ballot.
Bigger Picture and Reforms Suggested
The episode closes by arguing that Congress could restore trust and fairness through major reforms, including:
- Same-day registration
- Online voter registration
- Universal access to mail voting
- A ban on partisan gerrymandering
- Restoring the Voting Rights Act
- A meaningful, enforceable federal right to vote
Bottom Line
The episode’s core message is reassuring but cautious: Trump’s efforts have not fundamentally broken the midterm election process, largely because courts and state officials have held the line. Still, the campaign to discredit elections has had a real cost by fueling confusion and mistrust. The best antidote, the guest argues, is simple: participate, vote, and don’t let fear keep you home.