Overview of The Watch on The Ringer
Chris Ryan and Andy Greenwald open with their usual banter and then spend most of the episode on two TV conversations: the first five episodes of Beef Season 2 and Top Chef Season 23, Episode 7. Their Beef discussion is notably enthusiastic, with both hosts praising its writing, structure, and performances, while the Top Chef segment is more critical, focused on a frustrating Cracker Barrel-sponsored challenge and a messy elimination episode.
Pre-Show Pop-Culture News
Before the main TV discussion, the hosts riff on a few entertainment projects and industry-adjacent ideas:
- Michael Mann universe news: excitement about projects like Miami Vice 85 and the long-rumored Heat 2 adaptation.
- Copland as a series: they like the idea of turning James Mangold’s 1997 crime film into a TV show, especially because the premise lends itself naturally to serialized storytelling.
- They also joke about the growing overlap between prestige TV, film culture, and public-facing political/media personalities.
Beef Season 2, Episodes 1–5
Core Premise
This season follows two couples whose lives collide around a high-end country club in California:
- Josh and Lindsay — played by Jake Gyllenhaal and Carrie Mulligan
- Austin and Ashley — played by Charles Melton and Cailee Spaeny
A fight between the first couple is secretly recorded by the second, leading to blackmail, social maneuvering, and escalating emotional chaos.
What the Hosts Loved
The hosts were extremely high on the season, calling it one of the smartest and most compelling shows on TV.
Key strengths they highlighted:
-
Strong use of the smartphone era
- The show treats texting, deleting messages, Google searches, Instagram, and “recently deleted” folders as essential dramatic tools.
- They felt it captured how modern people perform their inner lives online.
-
Very precise contemporary detail
- Examples like celebrity name-drops, niche internet behavior, and specific lifestyle references make the show feel lived-in and current.
- They especially liked how the series uses tiny, recognizable details to reveal character psychology.
-
Emotional escalation that feels earned
- The show keeps turning fights into new complications instead of just recycling conflict.
- The hosts compared this favorably to how Succession handled aftermaths of major fights.
-
A broad but focused thematic scope
- The season explores love, class, status, deception, and the way relationships corrode at different life stages.
Performances
They were especially enthusiastic about the cast:
- Carrie Mulligan: praised as brilliant, with her character’s quick emotional toggling between blocking/unblocking people and spiraling over romantic and social betrayal.
- Charles Melton: singled out as excellent at playing a character who is both goofy and soulful.
- Cailee Spaeny: admired for making Ashley’s increasing resentment and emotional trajectory feel immediate and believable.
- Jake Gyllenhaal: the hosts were more divided, but still appreciated how his performance works in the show’s fights and status games.
- Oscar Isaac: one host was warmer on him than the other, but both noted how well he works in the emotional confrontations.
- Youn Yuh-jung and Song Kang-ho: they loved the addition of the Korean corporate/world-building layer, saying it expands the show’s canvas without weakening the core couple drama.
Episode Highlights Mentioned
- The couple’s failed B&B/“BB&B” dream in episode 3
- The hospital sequence in episode 4, where Ashley’s medical crisis is tied to the stolen video and the show’s ongoing theme of access, class, and healthcare
- Lindsay’s spiral over Burberry the dog in episode 5
- The hosts especially liked how the show balances blackmail, romance, jealousy, and social climbing without becoming plot-only television
Main Takeaway
They see Beef as a rare example of a show that fully understands how people live, fight, and lie in the smartphone era. Even when the plotting gets big, they felt the emotional logic stayed sharp.
Top Chef Season 23, Episode 7
What Happened
This episode revolved around a Cracker Barrel challenge and was split into several frustrating parts:
- A quickfire / challenge involving making Cracker Barrel-style food
- A dessert-focused elimination round judged by local fans in Charlotte
- A big shift in the episode when Jennifer suffered a health issue, including what sounded like Bell’s palsy, which led to her leaving the competition
Hosts’ Reaction
They were broadly unimpressed with the episode.
Main criticisms:
- Corporate tie-in overload: they disliked the Cracker Barrel integration and felt the branding overwhelmed the actual competition.
- Too much studio-only cooking: they prefer when Top Chef gets out into the world and feels less confined.
- Dessert challenge fatigue: neither host likes when the show forces most chefs to make desserts, especially if that isn’t their strength.
- Weak contestant pool: they felt this season’s cast lacks a standout dominant chef compared to stronger recent seasons.
Elimination Drama
- Justin was sent to Last Chance Kitchen after Jennifer’s medical exit.
- He initially chose to step away and be with Jennifer, then later returned to compete in Last Chance Kitchen after learning she was okay.
- The hosts found the handling of the situation clunky and under-explained, especially the way the show teased mystery around who would return.
Bottom Line on the Episode
They thought the episode was one of the weakest of the season because it combined:
- a corporate sponsor challenge,
- a dessert-heavy format,
- and a claustrophobic, overly staged setup.
Even so, they still see the season as solid overall from an editorial/vibes standpoint.
Final Thoughts
- Beef was the clear winner of the episode discussion: sharp, timely, and emotionally rich.
- Top Chef got more criticism, mostly for format and sponsorship issues rather than total failure.
- The hosts ended by teasing that they’ll continue discussing both shows next episode, along with other TV and sports chatter.