Sony Film CEO on Losing ‘Sinners’ and the Endless Big Tech Battle

Summary of Sony Film CEO on Losing ‘Sinners’ and the Endless Big Tech Battle

by The Ringer

28m•February 23, 2026
Listen to Episode

Overview of The Town — Sony Film CEO on Losing ‘Sinners’ and the Endless Big Tech Battle

This episode of The Town (host Matt Bellamy, The Ringer) features Tom Rothman, chairman and CEO of Sony Pictures Motion Picture Group, speaking live at the AFI Conservatory. The conversation centers on the current disruption in Hollywood driven by hyperscale tech companies, the “windows” crisis for theatrical releases, Sony’s strategy as a studio without its own general-interest streaming platform, the studio’s recent successes (including K-pop: Demon Slayer on Netflix), and Rothman’s reflections on losing the rights to Ryan Coogler’s Sinners. The episode is the first of a two-part interview.

Key topics discussed

  • The five major disruptive shifts in the movie business (Rothman’s framework):
    • Invention of sound
    • End of the old studio system
    • Invention of television / home entertainment
    • Analog-to-digital transition
    • Current entry of hyperscale tech companies into film/TV
  • Hyperscale tech impact:
    • Trillion-dollar platforms (Netflix, Amazon, Apple, etc.) can subsidize content and play by different economics.
    • They compete directly for big-budget, top-tier projects and can condition audiences on shorter release windows.
  • The “windows” problem:
    • COVID accelerated changes and risky short-window experiments.
    • Short theatrical exclusivity weakens the incentive to go to cinemas and raises the theatrical bar for what audiences will attend.
    • Protecting theatrical exclusivity is essential for the health of the exhibition and theatrical-first movies.
  • Sony’s position and strategy:
    • Sony is unique among major studios in not owning a general-interest streaming platform; that makes them attractive partners/sellers to streamers.
    • The studio emphasizes creativity and “making dope shit” — originality and quality over brute volume.
    • Sony benefits from repeat partnerships with filmmakers and a valuable film library.
  • Deals with streamers:
    • Sony renewed a lucrative “pay-one” deal with Netflix (first pay TV window), generating substantial revenue.
    • K-pop: Demon Slayer became Netflix’s biggest movie ever, demonstrating Netflix’s strength for certain titles (word-of-mouth, repeat viewing, global reach).
  • The Sinners situation:
    • Ryan Coogler’s Sinners (deal structure included copyright reversion after 25 years) was sold away from Sony; Rothman says he offered more money but declined accepting a deal that would set a precedent of surrendering long-term library rights.
    • Rothman regrets not having the film but defends prioritizing the studio’s enduring library value.
  • Filmmaker relationships:
    • Rothman emphasizes being a filmmaker-friendly executive, citing multiple repeat collaborations (Danny Boyle, Sam Mendes).
    • He notes he’d still like to work with a few filmmakers he hasn’t yet (e.g., Christopher Nolan).

Main takeaways

  • We’re in a decisive, historic moment for film distribution driven by hyperscale tech firms; the industry must respond strategically to protect its long-term economics and cultural role.
  • Theatrical exclusivity matters: shortening or eroding windows damages the theatrical experience and conditioning of audiences.
  • Studios’ libraries are their enduring economic and cultural assets; giving up long-term rights can undermine the studio model.
  • Sony’s lack of a proprietary streaming service is both a weakness and an advantage — it forces them to be a better creative partner and makes them attractive to streamers for licensing and production partnerships.
  • Streaming platforms and studios each have strengths: platforms can amplify word-of-mouth and repeat viewing (great for some titles), while studios excel at marketing, theatrical releases, and filmmaker relationships.
  • Quality and marketing still win: “Make dope shit” — craft and promotion that create audience buzz are critical, especially for theatrical success.

Notable quotes / sharp insights

  • On the current disruption: “This is the fifth… climacteric” in the history of the movie business (placing the tech entry alongside prior structural shifts).
  • On competition with tech platforms: “Because they're scaled, they don't have to play by Hollywood's rule… they actually don't have to make profit.”
  • On what studios can do better than tech firms: “Make dope shit.”
  • On windows and audience behavior: referencing Casablanca — “Maybe not today or tomorrow, but soon.” (audiences expect home availability if windows shrink).
  • On the studio’s long-term value: “The profitability that underlines a movie studio is its library. That's the enduring value.”

Practical implications / recommendations

For studio executives:

  • Defend theatrical exclusivity windows strategically; negotiate windows that preserve the theatrical incentive for story-driven films.
  • Treat library ownership as a core, long-term asset when structuring deals (avoid routine reversion terms that erode catalog value).
  • Leverage talent relationships and repeat collaborations to sustain creative quality.

For filmmakers:

  • Be aware that different release strategies suit different films (animated, franchise, or word-of-mouth titles may thrive on streaming; some projects still need theatrical windows to reach full value).
  • Understand long-term rights (copyright reversion, ownership) and how they affect both immediate financing and legacy value.

For streaming/platform executives:

  • Collaborating with legacy studios provides access to curated IP and theatrical marketing muscle; scale is a strength, but marketing and theatrical know-how remain valuable.

Episode details

  • Guest: Tom Rothman — Chairman and CEO, Sony Pictures Motion Picture Group (since 2015), former Fox executive and founder of Fox Searchlight.
  • Host: Matt Bellamy (The Ringer, Puck)
  • Format: Live interview at AFI Conservatory; part one of a two-part conversation (part two posted the following day).
  • Notable examples cited: K-pop: Demon Slayer (Netflix), Sinners (Ryan Coogler), Spider-Man and other upcoming Sony titles, Sony Pictures Animation/Imageworks growth.
  • Tone: Strategic, candid, occasionally nostalgic; Rothman mixes industry history with hard-nosed business reasoning and clear filmmaker advocacy.

This summary covers the core arguments and practical lessons from Rothman’s first session. Part two continues the conversation on related studio strategy and filmmaker relationships.