PMS 2.0 1648 - Overreaction Monday LIVE from Levi's Stadium with Adam Schefter & Dan Orlovsky

Summary of PMS 2.0 1648 - Overreaction Monday LIVE from Levi's Stadium with Adam Schefter & Dan Orlovsky

by Pat McAfee, ESPN

2h 35m•October 19, 2026
Listen to Episode

Overview of PMS 2.0 1648 - Overreaction Monday LIVE from Levi's Stadium with Adam Schefter & Dan Orlovsky

Pat McAfee and the crew hosted a live Overreaction Monday from Levi’s Stadium ahead of Commanders vs. 49ers, using the NFL’s wild Week 6 slate to debate the league’s biggest takeaways. The show centered on major organizational shakeups, breakout teams, injury news, and a long conversation with Adam Schefter about Jalen Hurts, Micah Parsons, Lamar Jackson, Josh Jacobs, and the status of the international game in Paris. Later, Dan Orlovsky broke down the biggest on-field trends, including Caleb Williams, C.J. Stroud, Jordan Love, Josh Allen, and why the Packers, Chiefs, and Bills are trending up.

Biggest NFL Storylines

Colts fire Chris Ballard

  • The biggest news of the morning was Chris Ballard being dismissed by the Colts after 10 seasons.
  • Pat argued the move was long overdue after years of quarterback instability, no AFC South titles, and a culture that never translated into enough wins.
  • The crew debated what happens next for Indianapolis:
    • whether assistant GM Ed Dodds should lead a broader reset,
    • whether Shane Steichen is safe,
    • and whether the Colts should trade older veterans for draft capital.

Colts roster decisions could define the next era

  • Names discussed as potential trade or core pieces included:
    • Jonathan Taylor
    • Quenton Nelson
    • DeForest Buckner
    • Alec Pierce
    • Daniel Jones
  • The main question: keep building around expensive veterans, or start a real teardown/reload?

Packers look legit after beating the Cowboys

  • The panel was impressed by Green Bay’s defense, especially how it handled Dak Prescott and Dallas’ pressure issues.
  • Jordan Love was praised for playing well enough, while the defense did the heavy lifting.
  • Orlovsky suggested Green Bay could end up being one of the best teams in the NFC if the defense keeps playing at that level.

Steelers survive a wild comeback

  • Pittsburgh’s comeback win was treated as a major sign that this Steelers team may be different from past versions.
  • The fourth-quarter rally and overtime finish were framed as the kind of game the Steelers used to lose.
  • The show also spent time on Mike McCarthy’s injury and whether he’d be okay for the team’s upcoming trip to France.

Patriots and Drake Maye keep surging

  • The crew loved what they’ve seen from Drake Maye and Mike Vrabel’s influence in New England.
  • The Patriots were described as “back,” with Maye playing decisive, efficient football and dealing well with injuries around him.

Josh Allen keeps doing Josh Allen things

  • Allen’s scramble-and-throw touchdown against the Raiders was one of the show’s signature highlights.
  • The panel leaned into the idea that Allen can make something happen on any snap, even if it sometimes comes with turnover-worthy chaos.
  • The Bills’ defense was still a concern, but Allen’s ability to carry the team remained the headline.

Browns at 4-2

  • Cleveland was praised as one of the surprise stories of the season.
  • The Browns’ comeback win and improvement under their coaching staff made them a popular overreaction topic.
  • The takeaway: this doesn’t feel like “same old Browns” right now.

Ravens, Rams, Cowboys, Chargers raise concerns

  • Baltimore was criticized for repeatedly blowing leads and losing games they should close.
  • The Rams were called disappointing relative to preseason expectations.
  • Dallas drew heavy criticism for poor answers against blitzes and bad offensive structure.
  • The Chargers were singled out as one of the most disappointing teams in football, with questions about scheme fit and Justin Herbert’s frustration.

Adam Schefter Interview: Key Injury and League Updates

Jalen Hurts’ situation is the scariest news of the day

  • Schefter explained that Hurts’ issue began with a cleat-related calf injury that led to a blood clot.
  • The clot later moved and eventually reached his lungs, which made the situation much more serious.
  • Hurts is now stable, but the expectation is that he is out for at least three months, effectively ending his season.
  • The panel stressed that the health aspect matters far more than football.

Micah Parsons: no firm return date

  • Schefter said Parsons has not had his practice window opened yet and is not expected back immediately.
  • The Cowboys will likely wait until he is fully healthy rather than rush him back.

Lamar Jackson: likely back soon, but only when healthy

  • Schefter said Lamar’s return depends on how he feels physically.
  • He suggested Jackson may be back soon, but the Ravens are not forcing it.

Josh Jacobs expected to play

  • Schefter said Jacobs should be available, though the league could still review additional information later.

Saints-Steelers in Paris will go on

  • Despite reports of unrest in France, Schefter confirmed the NFL game in Paris is still scheduled to happen.
  • The league and teams are proceeding as planned.

Dan Orlovsky’s Football Takeaways

Caleb Williams looked his best under Ben Johnson

  • Orlovsky said this may have been Caleb’s best game with Ben Johnson as his coach.
  • He praised Caleb’s poise, pocket management, and rhythm.
  • The connection with Luther Burden was highlighted as a major positive.

C.J. Stroud is playing at an elite level

  • Orlovsky said Stroud is seeing the field more cleanly than ever and is handling pressure better than in previous seasons.
  • He believes Stroud is beginning to enter MVP-type territory if the Texans keep winning.

Chiefs are evolving into a complete team

  • The Chiefs were praised for changing their offensive identity and becoming more balanced.
  • Orlovsky emphasized:
    • better run-game commitment,
    • more formation variety,
    • improved line play,
    • and an evolving offense that helps Mahomes.
  • The team was described as looking more complete top to bottom than in past seasons.

Cowboys’ pressure problems are coaching and execution

  • Orlovsky was blunt that Dallas does not have a good answer for blitz looks and changing defensive pictures.
  • He said the issue is both schematic and execution-based, and that Dak and the coaching staff aren’t handling pressure well.

Chargers are a major disappointment

  • He said the offense and Herbert/coach fit look broken.
  • The Chargers’ offensive production was described as historically bad, and a change may be inevitable.

College Football Recap

BYU’s upset over Notre Dame stole the Saturday spotlight

  • Pat’s trip to Provo and BYU’s win over Notre Dame was a major highlight.
  • The show loved the atmosphere, the storming of the field, and the culture around the program.
  • Bear Bachmeier was praised for a standout performance.

Wild weekend across college football

  • The crew also recapped a chaotic Saturday with major results and near-upsets:
    • Alabama/Tennessee
    • Florida State/Miami
    • Ohio State/Indiana
    • Auburn’s big finish
    • Texas/Florida, Oklahoma/Kentucky, and others
  • The general theme: college football continues to deliver unpredictable, high-drama Saturdays.

Final Takeaways

  • The Colts firing Chris Ballard was the show’s biggest NFL business story.
  • Jalen Hurts’ blood clot situation was the most serious news item overall.
  • The Packers, Patriots, Steelers, Browns, and Chiefs all got positive attention as rising or resurgent teams.
  • The Cowboys, Ravens, Chargers, and Rams were the main disappointment teams.
  • The show closed by looking ahead to Commanders vs. 49ers on ESPN2 Field Pass, with the 49ers favored but the crew expecting another unpredictable NFL finish.