PMS 2.0 1555 - PGA Championship Recap, Adam Schefter, Mike Tirico, Erik Johnson, Shams Charania, Darius Butler, & AJ Hawk

Summary of PMS 2.0 1555 - PGA Championship Recap, Adam Schefter, Mike Tirico, Erik Johnson, Shams Charania, Darius Butler, & AJ Hawk

by Pat McAfee, ESPN

2h 52mMay 18, 2026

Overview of PMS 2.0 1555

This episode was a fast-moving Monday sports roundup centered on the day’s biggest headlines: Aaron Rodgers officially signing with the Pittsburgh Steelers, a heated debate over Shams Charania leaking the NBA MVP news, the PGA Championship win by England’s Aaron Rai, and previews of a huge night in the NHL and NBA playoffs. The crew also spent a lot of time on guest interviews, including Mike Tirico, Adam Schefter, and Eric Johnson, while weaving in plenty of side topics like country music, banana ball, MMA, and a very Pat McAfee-style detour into aliens.

Biggest Sports Headlines

Aaron Rodgers officially joins the Steelers

  • Schefter confirmed Rodgers signed a one-year deal worth around $22–23 million, with incentives up to $25 million.
  • Rodgers was back in Pittsburgh and already at OTAs, which the show framed as a big sign of commitment.
  • The Steelers appear to believe Rodgers gives them the best chance to win now, even if the move also creates questions about the future of the quarterback room.
  • The crew discussed how the organization seemed to expect this move more than the fanbase did.

NBA MVP leak controversy: Shams Charania

  • The show devoted a long segment to Shams Charania breaking the Shai Gilgeous-Alexander MVP news before the official announcement.
  • Blake Griffin’s criticism of the leak became a running joke, but Shams defended his position:
    • If he gets confirmed news, his job is to report it.
    • He said he vets the information and feels a responsibility to publish it.
  • The crew also revisited the larger issue of insider culture in sports media and whether “breaking” news this way is fair game.

Giannis trade speculation

  • Schefter and Shams both addressed the ongoing possibility that Giannis Antetokounmpo could be moved, with teams like the Celtics, Heat, Knicks, Lakers, and Timberwolves mentioned as potential suitors.
  • The conversation emphasized that Milwaukee is still gauging whether it has the right package and whether Giannis truly wants a change.

Patrick Mahomes injury update

  • Schefter said Mahomes is ahead of schedule and tracking toward being ready for the season opener.
  • The discussion focused on the fact that, even if he plays early, he may not be fully himself right away after a significant knee injury.

Malik Nabers injury update

  • Schefter flagged concern over Malik Nabers having a second surgery to clean up scar tissue.
  • The crew discussed the reality of scar tissue in rehabs and why a second procedure is usually not ideal, even if it’s ultimately precautionary.

NBA Playoff Preview and Reactions

Thunder vs. Spurs

  • Mike Tirico previewed Game 1 of the Western Conference Finals, calling it a matchup of two elite, young, deep teams.
  • The show framed the series as:
    • Wembanyama vs. SGA
    • Unicorn vs. MVP
    • Future of the league on display
  • SGA was described as being in a historic run:
    • Back-to-back MVPs
    • Elite efficiency
    • A rare place in NBA history alongside the all-time greats

Pistons-Cavs reaction

  • The crew was blunt that Detroit’s Game 7 loss was a disappointment and that Cleveland looked dominant.
  • The Cavs’ win was presented as a major moment for Donovan Mitchell and the franchise.
  • Mike the Miz sent in a video joking about Detroit’s collapse and hyping Cleveland’s next round.

Knicks and the East

  • There was brief talk about the Knicks and the conference finals path, with Shams noting OG Anunoby should be ready for Game 1.

NHL Playoff Talk

Canadiens vs. Sabres Game 7

  • The show treated the NHL Game 7 as the night’s other major event.
  • Eric Johnson joined to break down the series and explained why:
    • Montreal’s power play could be the difference
    • Home ice hasn’t been as important this postseason as people expect
    • Buffalo has been shaky at home
  • Johnson liked Montreal’s chances, citing:
    • Jake Allen/goalie play after losses
    • The Canadiens’ strong road form
    • Power-play opportunities as a key live-betting angle

John Tortorella and the media fine

  • Johnson gave a player’s perspective on the controversy around Torts refusing media availability, saying he understood both sides.
  • He described Tortorella as intense, direct, and old-school, with a style that calls players out in front of the whole team.

Hockey details and culture

  • Johnson also gave fun behind-the-scenes insight into:
    • Custom stick curves
    • Nicknames in hockey culture
    • His own “Big Horny” nickname from a coach
    • Why star players like Sidney Crosby use different stick setups

PGA Championship Recap

Aaron Rai wins

  • The crew celebrated Aaron Rai winning the PGA Championship, correcting the transcript’s “Aaron Rye.”
  • Rai’s win was highlighted as historic:
    • First Englishman in 107 years to win a major
  • The show liked the Sunday tension even though some players complained about the course setup.
  • Rai’s two-glove style became a talking point, with several people admitting they might try it themselves.

Course and tournament notes

  • The course was described as extremely difficult, especially on Sunday.
  • The crew wanted more movement and scoring swings, but still enjoyed Rai’s clutch finish.

Mike Tirico Interview Highlights

  • Tirico was excellent throughout the segment and praised the Thunder-Spurs matchup as a series people have wanted for a long time.
  • He pointed out:
    • Oklahoma City has been ahead of schedule
    • San Antonio has the kind of young, explosive star that can change a series
  • He explained why Wembanyama’s physical style matters and why SGA’s MVP-level production is historically rare.
  • Tirico also chatted about:
    • Golf equipment and putters
    • The idea of “message sent, reply” in playoff basketball
    • The energy of big-game broadcasts

Eric Johnson Interview Highlights

  • Johnson joined fresh from a Cabo golf trip and joked his golf game is “like my abs: they’re there, you just can’t see them.”
  • He previewed the rest of the NHL playoffs, especially:
    • Colorado vs. Vegas
    • Goaltending as the biggest series swing factor
  • He also touched on:
    • His love for horse racing
    • Ownership/breeding horses
    • The adrenaline of watching one of his horses win a race

Other Fun Topics and Sidebars

Country music and the ACM Awards

  • The crew spent a lot of time recapping the Academy of Country Music Awards in Las Vegas.
  • They loved the energy from:
    • Riley Green
    • Shaboozey
    • Cody Johnson
    • Bublé
    • Red Clay Strays
  • There was a lot of talk about how fun and weirdly sports-adjacent country music events feel.

Banana Ball and other “fun sports”

  • The show loved Banana Ball, praising the production, music, fan interaction, and the fact that it’s a real event even if it feels like a circus.
  • Jesse Cole’s approach got a ton of praise.

MMA and combat sports

  • They also recapped a Netflix/MVP fight night:
    • Ronda Rousey dominated quickly
    • Mike Perry beat Nate Diaz
    • Francis Ngannou returned and looked terrifying as usual
  • There was mention of a separate influencer/combat card with Johnny Manziel, but much of it was played for laughs.

Aliens detour

  • In typical McAfee-show fashion, the conversation veered into aliens, the “Nordic” and “reptilian” species, and whether sports fans should worry about extraterrestrials entering the league.

Key Takeaways

  • Aaron Rodgers to the Steelers was the biggest NFL story of the day.
  • Shams Charania defended his decision to leak the MVP winner early.
  • Shai Gilgeous-Alexander vs. Victor Wembanyama is being framed as a potential long-term NBA rivalry.
  • Aaron Rai’s PGA Championship win was the feel-good golf story of the weekend.
  • Montreal vs. Buffalo and Colorado vs. Vegas were the hockey matchups to watch.
  • The episode blended serious sports news with the show’s usual mix of chaos, humor, and off-the-wall side conversations.