Israel And Hamas Agree To First Phase Of Peace Deal

Summary of Israel And Hamas Agree To First Phase Of Peace Deal

by NPR

17m•October 9, 2025
Listen to Episode

Summary — "Israel And Hamas Agree To First Phase Of Peace Deal" (NPR Politics Podcast)

Overview

This episode explains a negotiated first phase of a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas intended to halt the Gaza war and set up a broader transition. The deal contains multiple interlocking steps — a limited Israeli troop pullback, a timed release of Israeli hostages by Hamas, reciprocal Palestinian prisoner releases by Israel, and a scale-up of humanitarian aid — but many key details remain unresolved. The episode also examines former President Trump’s central diplomatic role and the political and practical hurdles ahead.

Key Points & Main Takeaways

  • Agreement structure and immediate timeline:

    • The Israeli government must formally approve the deal; a public announcement triggers the ceasefire.
    • Israel has ~24 hours to partially pull back troops inside Gaza (not a full withdrawal).
    • Hamas is given three days to release Israeli hostages (reportedly ~20 alive, ~28 believed dead).
    • Once hostage releases begin, Israel will start releasing up to ~2,000 Palestinian prisoners/detainees.
    • Hundreds of aid trucks are slated to enter Gaza to address severe humanitarian needs.

  • Role of the U.S. and President Trump:

    • Trump played a leading role pressuring Israeli and Arab actors, convening talks at the U.N. and leveraging Arab-state involvement.
    • He released a 20-point plan that calls for Hamas disarmament, creation of a “Board of Peace” (which he would chair), and a path toward reconstruction and possible Palestinian self-governance. Many elements are not fully agreed upon.

  • Why this may — or may not — hold:

    • Differences from past ceasefires: stronger international/Arab pressure and Hamas being militarily weakened.
    • Major hurdles remain: Hamas has not committed to disarmament; Israeli forces remain in Gaza; no clear timeline or enforcement mechanism for long-term governance.
    • Public sentiment: relief and cautious hope coexist with deep grief and anger on both sides.

  • Governance and reconstruction uncertainty:

    • Interim governance is proposed to be a committee of Palestinian technocrats overseen by a Board of Peace; selection, authority, and enforcement are vague.
    • Palestinian Authority involvement is considered weak due to its low standing and leadership concerns.
    • Funding and timing for reconstruction (Trump suggested wealthy Arab states will pay) are unclear.

  • Political implications:

    • Trump will claim credit domestically; foreign policy wins rarely shift broad approval but this is a high-visibility accomplishment amid domestic political weakness.
    • Netanyahu faced internal criticism; some Israelis blame his delays for hostage deaths.

Notable Quotes / Insights

  • President Trump: "Last night, we reached a momentous breakthrough... We ended the war in Gaza and really, on a much bigger basis, created peace... Peace in the Middle East."
  • Trump on hostages: "We're getting all the hostages out at the beginning."
  • A Palestinian father in Gaza: "What should I be happy about? I'm living in a tent with my children... I've lost 150 of my extended family members."
  • An Israeli man (whose father died in captivity): He blamed Netanyahu, saying a deal "could have been reached a long time ago when my father was still alive."

Topics Discussed

  • Terms and timeline of the first phase ceasefire
  • Hostage release and reciprocal prisoner releases
  • Israeli troop movements and security concerns
  • Humanitarian aid flow into Gaza
  • Proposed interim governance (technocrats, Board of Peace) and long-term political questions
  • Trump’s 20-point plan and diplomatic role (including Jared Kushner’s involvement)
  • Regional actors (Egypt, Qatar, Arab states) and international pressure
  • Public reaction in Israel and Gaza; emotional and political responses
  • Risks of breakdown and escalation; past ceasefire comparisons
  • Political implications for Trump and Netanyahu

Action Items / What to Watch Next

  • Israeli cabinet vote and formal announcement (starts the official countdown).
  • Exact timelines after announcement:
    • 24-hour Israeli partial troop pullback window.
    • 3-day window for Hamas to release hostages.
    • Start of Israeli release of up to ~2,000 Palestinian prisoners once hostages begin to be freed.
  • Actual release of hostages (verification of numbers and survivors) and timing of prisoner releases.
  • Flow and distribution of humanitarian aid: trucks entering Gaza and whether aid reaches civilians.
  • Implementation details of interim governance: who is on the technocrat committee, how they’re selected, enforcement mechanisms.
  • Whether Hamas will accept disarmament or maintain armed presence (major risk factor).
  • Trump’s follow-up actions, possible visit, and how the proposed Board of Peace will function and be funded.
  • Signs of escalation: clashes near remaining Israeli forces in Gaza or breakdown in hostage/prisoner exchange.

Bottom Line

The first-phase deal creates a concrete, time-bound framework for a ceasefire, hostage releases, reciprocal prisoner exchanges, and emergency aid — and it reflects intense diplomatic pressure led by Trump and regional actors. However, the agreement is fragile: key elements (Hamas disarmament, troop withdrawal, interim governance, reconstruction funding) are vague or disputed, and the presence of Israeli forces in Gaza plus unresolved political questions pose clear risks of relapse into violence. The coming days (hostage releases, prisoner releases, aid flows) will be the critical test of whether this first phase holds.