S6 Ep48: Heather Cox Richardson: America's 250 Great (and Awful) Years

Summary of S6 Ep48: Heather Cox Richardson: America's 250 Great (and Awful) Years

by The Bulwark

1h 7m•July 4, 2026
Listen to Episode

Overview of S6 Ep48: Heather Cox Richardson: America’s 250 Great (and Awful) Years

This episode of The Bulwark’s Focus Group explores how Democrats and other Americans are feeling about the country as the U.S. approaches its 250th anniversary. Sarah Longwell and Heather Cox Richardson discuss the tension between patriotism and pride, the psychological damage of Trump’s second election, and why many voters feel both deeply attached to America’s ideals and deeply ashamed of its current direction. The conversation blends focus-group reactions with a broader historical argument: America has always been a mix of greatness and failure, and the way forward is not nostalgia but participation, reform, and a renewed commitment to democratic principles.

Core Themes

America’s 250th anniversary is landing in a moment of national unease

  • The episode frames the 4th of July and America’s semiquincentennial as a moment that could have been unifying, but instead feels complicated by Trump-era politics.
  • Polling cited in the conversation suggests Americans—especially Democrats—are less likely to say they are “proud” to be American, even if they still consider themselves patriotic.
  • The hosts note that many voters feel conflicted: they still love the country, but are embarrassed by its current behavior and leadership.

Patriotism vs. pride

  • A key distinction in the discussion is that a person can be patriotic without feeling proud of the country right now.
  • Heather argues that patriotism is less about uncritical celebration and more about commitment to America’s founding principles and the work of improving the country.
  • Longwell adds that Trump has made many people feel like the worst parts of the country are being amplified and rewarded.

Trump has deepened the crisis of confidence

  • Several voters describe feeling ashamed of the U.S. because of Trump, U.S. policy, and how the country is perceived abroad.
  • Heather says the second Trump presidency has intensified the sense that America is not living up to its own ideals.
  • She also argues that a major problem is that many Americans no longer feel they are participants in self-government—they feel like subjects.

Heather Cox Richardson’s Historical Argument

America has always been both “great” and “awful”

  • Heather’s central thesis: every year in U.S. history has contained both achievement and moral failure.
  • She rejects the idea that patriotism requires denial of the country’s darkest chapters.
  • Instead, she says America’s story is one of recurring conflict, reinvention, and the slow expansion of rights.

Historical cycles of tension

  • She points to previous 50-year anniversary moments:
    • 1776/1876: Reconstruction-era conflicts and the unfinished work of emancipation.
    • 1926: deep class and regional divisions during the roaring economy.
    • 1976: the bicentennial amid Watergate, Vietnam’s aftermath, and broader cultural change.
  • Her point: anniversaries often trigger reflection, but they also expose unresolved national tensions.

Democracy requires citizens, not spectators

  • Heather emphasizes that American democracy depends on ordinary people “putting skin in the game.”
  • She argues that civic renewal comes from participation:
    • voting
    • volunteering
    • serving on school boards
    • community organizing
    • helping neighbors
  • Her advice is practical and grounded: build community, stay involved, and don’t underestimate small acts of civic engagement.

What Voters Said

The dominant mood: embarrassment, grief, and fatigue

  • Many voters said they feel ashamed of the U.S. in the Trump era.
  • Common concerns included:
    • cruelty toward immigrants and other countries
    • disrespect for democracy and the rule of law
    • the feeling that the country has become more divisive and less decent
  • Some said they no longer feel comfortable celebrating the 4th of July in the traditional way.

But many still hold onto hope

  • Even conflicted voters said they believe this is a dark chapter, not the end of the story.
  • They expressed pride in:
    • their family histories
    • immigrant success stories
    • scientific and medical progress
    • civil rights and women’s rights
    • people protesting and fighting for democracy
  • Several people stressed that America’s promise is still real, even if it is badly compromised in the present.

“The people, not the politics”

  • One recurring idea was that America is made by ordinary people, not the government or the current political class.
  • The World Cup and similar cultural moments were mentioned as reminders that Americans can be warm, welcoming, and fun when the focus is on people rather than politics.

What Heather Says Should Change

Practical reforms she wants to see

Heather argues that restoring trust in democracy will require major structural reform. Her top priorities included:

  • Get big money out of politics

    • Repeal or overturn Citizens United
    • Reduce the role of wealthy donors and dark money

  • Restore accountability

    • End the culture of impunity
    • Reject the idea that presidents or officials are above the law

  • Reform the courts

    • Consider expanding the Supreme Court
    • Reverse the current right-wing capture of the judiciary

  • Fix representation

    • Rework the Electoral College so it reflects voters more fairly
    • Address the imbalance in the Senate
    • Support D.C. statehood
    • Reconsider how House districts are structured so citizens feel represented

Why reform matters

  • Heather argues that if people keep feeling unrepresented, faith in democracy will continue to erode.
  • She sees reform not as radicalism, but as necessary maintenance for a functioning republic.

Notable Insights

Ossoff as a model

  • Sarah Longwell highlights John Ossoff’s speech as a strong example of patriotic realism: celebrating America’s ideals without pretending the country is perfect.
  • Heather agrees, saying leaders should connect present-day problems to the nation’s founding principles.
  • She sees that kind of rhetoric as essential for rallying people around democracy.

History as a tool for hope

  • Heather repeatedly returns to the idea that history shows people can change the country.
  • She uses examples like:
    • the Civil War generation
    • the civil rights movement
    • the evolution of public opinion on gay marriage
  • Her view is that change often happens bottom-up, through persuasion, activism, and persistence.

Key Takeaways

  • Many Americans, especially Democrats, feel pride and shame at the same time.
  • Trump has intensified distrust in institutions and damaged people’s emotional relationship with the country.
  • Heather Cox Richardson argues that America’s story has always included both moral triumph and moral failure.
  • The path forward is not to romanticize the past, but to rebuild democracy through participation, reform, and accountability.
  • Americans can recover pride by helping make the country better, not just by celebrating it.

Bottom Line

The episode is ultimately a defense of engaged, reform-minded patriotism. Heather Cox Richardson argues that America is neither uniquely noble nor uniquely broken—it is a country defined by struggle, contradiction, and reinvention. The challenge of the 250th anniversary is to stop asking whether America has been “good” or “bad” and start asking what citizens are willing to do to make it better.