Overview of Erin & Sara Foster: Everybody Wants This!!!
Amanda Hirsch sits down with Erin and Sara Foster for a playful, wide-ranging conversation about the return of Nobody Wants This, their sisterly creative partnership, and the personal experiences that shaped the show’s biggest moments. The episode mixes behind-the-scenes TV talk with a lot of candid banter about motherhood, Jewish identity, social media, dating, anxiety, and what it means to build success in an authentic way.
What They Talked About
Nobody Wants This Season 3 and the Show’s Impact
- Erin and Sara discuss the new season of Nobody Wants This and how excited they are for viewers to watch it.
- They tease that the season has bigger emotional and romantic payoffs, with twists fans won’t see coming.
- Amanda praises the show’s rise and how the Foster sisters have gone from under-the-radar creators to awards-season players.
Jewish Identity, Conversion, and Representation
- Erin explains that conversion was the original spark for creating the show.
- They discuss Joanne’s conversion storyline and why Erin wanted it to feel thoughtful and earned rather than rushed.
- Erin says the show is intended as a love letter to Judaism and wants Jewish viewers to feel seen.
- She also addresses Adam Brody’s critical comments about Israel, saying she respects differing opinions but stands by the show’s intent and the positive Jewish representation it offers.
- The conversation includes a discussion of the mikvah scene and how emotionally powerful it was to film.
Erin’s Cameo and the Proposal Episode
- Erin talks about playing Nicole, a character inspired by her own emotional conflict about “leaving behind” her single self.
- She reveals that the proposal storyline was based on her real engagement story.
- She explains that the scene had to work as an episode first, without giving away the proposal too early.
- The cameo was nerve-racking for Erin, but she felt supported by the cast and crew, and Amanda loved the performance.
Motherhood, Work, and Building a Life
- Erin opens up about becoming pregnant after years of trying, then returning to work during the writer’s strike and the show’s development.
- She says she’s proud of being a working mom and wants to model resilience for her daughter.
- Amanda and the sisters talk about the emotional challenge of balancing work, family, and long-distance parenting.
- Sara notes that Erin is deeply family-oriented and prioritizes home life in a way she admires.
The Foster Sisters’ Creative Dynamic
- They reflect on how much they’ve built together, from Barely Famous to their production company and current projects.
- Sara says Erin is the creator, but she’s still very involved in the bigger vision of the company and the show.
- Their sibling dynamic is affectionate but blunt:
- Erin says Sara is more stubborn and stands firm in her opinions.
- Sara says Erin is more judgmental and more intense about details.
- They joke about being “ride and die” for each other and about who is the favorite daughter.
Social Media, Public Perception, and “Organic” Success
- Erin says she’s less online than she used to be and no longer enjoys the overly curated, performative social media era.
- The sisters discuss how much social media has changed since the days when their irreverent, self-deprecating style felt fresh.
- They talk about how current culture pressures creators to have a podcast, a Substack, a beauty line, and a “brand ecosystem,” which Erin says can feel artificial.
- Sara shares that their success has always been more organic than formulaic.
Business, Influence, and What Actually Drives Sales
- The conversation turns to influencer marketing and the idea that posting alone doesn’t necessarily move product.
- Erin says celebrities and investors need to bring more than just social posts to the table.
- They discuss how they’ve tried to build real value through business involvement rather than just visibility.
Dating, Relationships, and What Sara Wants
- Sara admits she’s never really been on a traditional date and prefers organic connections.
- The sisters joke about whether she’d date a Jewish guy and what kind of partner would fit her best.
- Sara says she does not want to date an actor or musician and would prefer someone successful, grounded, and outside Hollywood.
Fears, Habits, and Personal Quirks
- They revisit old shared fears, including elevators and bathroom door locking.
- Amanda jokes about being the person on flights who keeps the window open.
- Erin says her fear of flying got worse after having kids because she thinks about leaving them motherless.
- The episode includes a running gag about beta blockers, with Erin revealing she took one before filming her acting scene because she was so nervous.
Notable Takeaways
The Show Means Something Bigger
- Erin sees Nobody Wants This as more than a rom-com; she sees it as a meaningful representation of Jewish life, romance, and conversion.
Erin and Sara’s Success Feels Earned
- Their conversation reflects years of building things that didn’t always work out before finally landing in a moment of real cultural relevance.
They’re Honest About the Messiness
- Whether they’re talking about family, careers, or dating, the sisters are frank about their flaws, preferences, and insecurities.
Their Bond Is the Core of Everything
- The episode works because their sibling chemistry is obvious: competitive, loving, brutally honest, and deeply supportive.
Memorable Quotes / Moments
- Erin describing the show as a “love letter to Judaism.”
- The sisters joking that Erin is the more judgmental one, while Sara is the one who “stands on business.”
- Erin saying she’s comfortable if this is the peak of her career because it already feels like her dream life.
- Amanda calling herself “ride and die” for the sisters, not “ride or die.”
Bottom Line
This episode is a funny, intimate, and surprisingly substantive conversation about the Foster sisters’ creative world. It covers the success of Nobody Wants This, the responsibility of Jewish storytelling, Erin’s emotional cameo, and the sisters’ very specific bond as collaborators, siblings, and business partners.