Trying In-N-Out For The First Time - H3 After Dark #115

Summary of Trying In-N-Out For The First Time - H3 After Dark #115

by Ethan Klein

2h 48m•October 20, 2026
Listen to Episode

Overview of H3 After Dark #115: Trying In-N-Out For The First Time

Ethan Klein is absent for most of this episode, as Harley, Kate, and David take over the studio for a chaotic guest-hosted After Dark. The episode jumps between food reviews, viral clips, phone calls from fans, internet oddities, and a few unusually earnest conversations about politics and women’s health. A big highlight is David’s first-ever In-N-Out taste test, which turns into a full-on fast-food debate and mini history lesson.

Main Topics Covered

Studio takeover chaos

  • Harley, Kate, and David jokingly “pirate” the H3 studio and run the show themselves.
  • The whole episode has a looser, more chaotic energy than usual, with lots of running jokes, teasing, and bit-by-bit improv.
  • They repeatedly joke about “firing” people, the new phone setup, and how weird it feels to be in Ethan’s chair.

David tries In-N-Out for the first time

  • David has never had In-N-Out, so the crew orders it for him live.
  • The group debates:
    • In-N-Out vs. Whataburger
    • Animal Style fries
    • whether the fries are undercooked
    • how much value the chain offers compared to other fast-food spots
  • David and the others mostly like the burger, especially the grilled onions and the cheese fries.
  • A former In-N-Out employee calls in and explains:
    • the standard burger comes with spread, not ketchup and mustard
    • Animal Style means mustard-cooked patties, cheese, and grilled onions
    • fries are best eaten immediately or ordered “light well”
    • customizations are a big part of In-N-Out culture
  • They also talk about secret-menu items and compare it to Del Taco and McDonald’s.

Fast-food history and burger lore

  • The crew dives into the story of Louis’ Lunch in New Haven, Connecticut, which claims to be the birthplace of the hamburger sandwich in the U.S.
  • They call the restaurant directly to confirm the origin story.
  • The restaurant explains:
    • the ground beef concept came from Hamburg, Germany
    • the sandwich form was created in the U.S.
  • The discussion becomes a playful but genuine food-history tangent.

Ringo Starr fan mail warning

  • The crew plays Ringo Starr’s public message asking people to stop sending fan mail after a certain date.
  • They joke about how overwhelmed he must have been and celebrate “Ringo fan mail day” as a weird H3 tradition.

Fan phone calls are back

  • The show announces the phone line is open again, now with a screening system.
  • Fans call in live, including:
    • a Kentucky caller who praises the show
    • a Maryland caller who recommends Ethiopian food
  • The crew jokes about geography, coastlines, and regional food culture.

Scary movie and reaction discussion

  • They talk about watching It at Cosm, the immersive theater venue.
  • Harley and Kate describe being extremely scared and reactive during the movie.
  • They discuss how horror movies play differently in a public setting and how theater food and sound design affect the experience.

Drunk politician interview / viral clip breakdown

  • They watch and react to a viral interview with a drunk political candidate, Jamie West.
  • She admits to having had “a couple” and then eventually says she had three beers before the interview.
  • She remains unapologetic and defiant, defending her anti-Republican comments.
  • The crew finds her chaotic honesty entertaining and jokes about her being a natural fit for a podcast.

Red Dead Redemption montage

  • A viewer-made compilation of Ethan accidentally shooting NPCs in Red Dead Redemption is shown.
  • Ethan explains:
    • it was his first real shooting game
    • he often accidentally killed people because he didn’t understand the controls
    • the game’s morality system made him feel guilty
  • The bit becomes a funny look at how chaotic and accidentally violent his gameplay was.

Bigfoot / cryptid discussion

  • They discuss the famous Patterson-Gimlin Bigfoot footage and a new documentary claiming to reveal more behind it.
  • Harley is skeptical, while the chat pushes back and argues that Bigfoot lore is tied to Indigenous stories and cryptid traditions.
  • The conversation expands into:
    • the Loch Ness Monster
    • Canadian cryptids like Ogopogo and Cadborosaurus
    • how much people want these creatures to be real
  • The segment is part skepticism, part fun folklore debate.

Black Republican voter gets kicked out of a rally

  • The crew covers a black Trump supporter who was kicked out of a Republican event and told she was mistaken for a “paid agitator.”
  • She seems genuinely confused and upset that she was treated this way despite being a longtime Republican voter.
  • The segment is used to highlight:
    • the paranoia and racial assumptions in some political spaces
    • how absurd it is that she was shocked by the treatment
  • They also mention Texas election context and encourage people to vote.

Brian Johnson’s “techno tampon” women’s health project

  • The final major segment covers Bryan Johnson’s shift from longevity obsession to studying women’s health.
  • He and his girlfriend Kate are doing an intense bio-measurement experiment:
    • thousands of biomarkers
    • multiple devices
    • millions of data points
  • Kate wears a sensor setup nicknamed the “techno tampon,” which they joke about heavily, but the project is framed as a real attempt to better understand female biology.
  • They note that women were historically left out of clinical trials and that the medical system still under-studies female bodies.
  • Ethan/Harley/Kate joke about the absurdity of the setup, but also acknowledge that the broader point has merit.

Notable Running Jokes and Bits

  • “Why are you gay?” singalong
  • “Shambhala” jokes and repeated sexual innuendo
  • constant threats to “shoot David” with the studio gun
  • “bean” jokes in reference to female anatomy
  • fake seriousness about the show’s chaotic production
  • recurring jokes about “gape,” “wipes,” and weird live-show logistics

Takeaways

  • This episode is mostly about chemistry, chaos, and improvisation rather than one single topic.
  • The most substantial segments are the In-N-Out taste test, the Bigfoot discussion, the drunk politician clip, and the Brian Johnson women’s health experiment.
  • The show leans hard into absurdity, but there are also a few surprisingly substantive moments, especially around food history and women being excluded from medical research.