Part 2: A Terrible Transformation | Starter Kit - Advanced D&D

Summary of Part 2: A Terrible Transformation | Starter Kit - Advanced D&D

by Critical Role

42mNovember 10, 2025

Overview of Part 2: A Terrible Transformation | Starter Kit — Advanced D&D

This episode (Starter Kit — Part 2) is an urban D&D play session run by DM David Nett for geekandsundry. The party investigates a violent scene in the city, encounters a horrific monster that emerges from a victim, chases it into the sewers, and returns with new clues tying gang activity and scavenger-monsters together. The episode balances combat and roleplay with practical examples of in-game mechanics (initiative, actions, reactions, spells, tracking) and offers a DM note about using nature-focused classes in city adventures.

Main beats / Episode flow

  • Recap of last session: team investigating a crime scene with gang symbols.
  • Combat: a young man reveals a monster (tentacled/mandibled creature) that emerges from his body mid-struggle.
  • The party fights the creature; individual PC turns and spell/attack outcomes are played out in detail.
  • The monster flees; the party pursues into the neighborhood, finds it went into the sewers, and tracks it.
  • Rats in the sewers provide partial directions (via druid/ranger interaction).
  • The party returns to the precinct with new evidence; the City Watch compiles findings. Lieutenant Smiles praises the group's progress and leaves them to follow up.
  • Tease for next episode: further investigation into gangs (harpies and the Rivers) and thief-quarter leads.

Characters/PCs present (brief)

  • Igneous — PC who is grappled and briefly paralyzed by the creature.
  • Narlak (Narlacc?) — Sorcerer casting Firebolt.
  • Araviel — Warlock who uses Toll the Dead, summons a magical flail (Gaelash/Galash), and casts Hex.
  • Shywin — Ranger (gloom stalker) with Hunter’s Mark and strong tracking/darkvision skills.
  • Leona — Melee fighter using a magical longsword.
  • Smiles — City Watch contact (supervisor) who later reviews evidence.
  • Lieutenant Wainwright/City Watch — investigators on the scene.
  • NPCs: harpy-marked and Rivers-gang suspects; unnamed boy who becomes the monster’s host.

Key plot developments & clues

  • The party discovers a monstrous carrion-crawler–like creature that emerges from a victim’s mouth/chest. It has tentacles, mandibles, and paralyzing attacks.
  • Combat details show the creature can paralyze (Con save DC 13), lash with tendrils, and scar/burn victims with tentacle burns.
  • After being wounded, the creature flees into nearby bushes and the sewers; the party loses it visually but tracks signs.
  • Investigation returns evidence that gang activity (harpies + Rivers) was present: bodies with harpy tattoos, three Rivers gang members, lockpicks, and a bag of stolen goods (including a necklace identified as belonging to Madame Flagstaff).
  • Forensics: some bodies were torn apart (tentacle-like wounds), others died from stabbing; mixed signs suggest either a fight between gangs or both targeted the same house.
  • Tracking in the sewers reveals an opened sewer grate; following the trail leads to a sewer crossroads where the scent is overwhelmed and the group consults sewer rats.
  • Rats identify a “big worm” with “worms on face” and point in conflicting directions; eventually confirm other cloaked people came back the way the party originally approached.
  • Party returns to the precinct; Smiles commends them but leaves them to continue investigation — episode ends with the party planning to pursue gang leads.

Combat & rules highlights (useful for players/DMs)

  • Initiative, movement, actions, bonus actions, reactions, and disengage mechanics were demonstrated in play.
  • Toll the Dead: warlock cantrip — target makes a Wisdom save (DC 13) vs necrotic damage (1d8 or 1d12 when missing HP).
  • Firebolt: ranged spell attack (sorcerer) used in melee environment (risk of friendly fire).
  • Paralyzing effect: creature’s tendril deals damage + forces a Constitution save to avoid paralysis.
  • Reactions: PCs can attack a creature as it disengages/runs past (single attack).
  • Hunter’s Mark and Hex: examples of bonus actions/bonuses to damage and skills (Hunter’s Mark adds 1d6 per hit; Hex grants extra necrotic and disadvantage on chosen ability checks — the party used Strength to hamper grapple attempts).
  • Tracking: Survival checks (with advantage from Hunter’s Mark in this session) to follow spoor; ranger/gloom stalker roleplay and darkvision advantage in sewers.

Notable roleplay moments / DM tips

  • DM note: urban campaigns don’t have to exclude nature-based classes. Druids, rangers, and barbarians can have meaningful and fun roles in cities (tracking, dealing with sewers and beasts, social encounters).
  • Effective use of environment in combat: cramped stairwell equals cover, limited melee options, and potential for friendly-fire/complicated movement.
  • Using animal interaction (animal handling / Speak With Animals / Circle abilities) to gather clues — rats as unreliable narrators but still helpful.

Items & evidence of interest

  • Bag of loot: jewelry (including Madame Flagstaff’s diamond choker), gold candlesticks, coins — suggests burglary.
  • Lockpicks found on a victim with the harpy tattoo.
  • Harpy tattoos on four bodies; Rivers gang mark (three bodies) found on other victims — implies multiple gangs present.
  • Carrion crawler–like physical evidence (claw/tentacle marks on walls, tentacle burns) — unusual behavior: crawling out of a human host.

Setting & tone

  • Urban, late-night investigation moving into a grimy sewer chase: gritty, tense, horror-tinged.
  • Tone mixes procedural investigation (City Watch procedures, evidence boards) with pulpy monster-horror.
  • Session blends combat choreography with clue gathering and roleplay/debriefing.

Sponsors & mid-episode reads (brief)

The episode includes multiple sponsored segments (Shopify, Progressive, Alienware, AG1, Thrive Cosmetics, Chime, Mint Mobile, Etsy, Apple/Watch) interspersed between play sections. (If you want to skip to gameplay, look for the DM and combat scenes.)

Takeaways / hooks for next episode

  • The creature is likely a carrion crawler (sewer-dwelling scavenger), but the transformation/possession aspect is new — carrion crawlers aren’t known to emerge from corpses or possess hosts.
  • The party will pursue leads in the thieves’ quarter, interrogate/track the harpies/Rivers gangs, and try to determine whether more of these creatures exist or if something else is causing the transformations.
  • Next episode teased: infiltration/negotiation with thieves’ quarter/harpies head, potential disguise and intimidation scenes.

If you need quick reference: the episode is an instructive example of urban D&D play—combat in tight spaces, using class features in nontraditional settings, and blending monster horror with investigative gameplay.